Accounting with Popeye

You might have heard the terms “cash basis accounting” or “accrual accounting.”  Your bottom-line net income can change depending on which method you use.  Here’s a simple explanation of the difference, with a little help from one of the most famous cartoon characters in history.

Popeye and Wimpy

You might recognize Popeye the Sailor Man from the television cartoons or other media.  His sidekick, Wimpy, was the one who was always hungry and always out of cash.  One of his favorite sayings was, “I’ll gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today.”

It’s All in the Timing

Let’s make today Thursday.  If Wimpy wants to pay us Tuesday for a hamburger today, here’s how it would be done for a restaurant on cash basis:

Cash basis recording Wimpy’s hamburger purchase

Both the sale and the receipt of cash would be recorded on Tuesday.  Companies on cash basis record the transaction only when the cash is received.

But, if the restaurant’s books were on the accrual basis, it would be a different story:

Accrual basis recording Wimpy’s hamburger purchase

Wimpy’s hamburger sale would be recorded on Thursday, the day he ate the hamburger.  The receipt would then be recorded on Tuesday, assuming Wimpy made good on his promise to pay.

You might be asking why a few days is such a big deal.  Outside of cartoon life, a couple of extra twists can happen.  It can be far more than a few days from the time you do the work to the time you get paid for it.  And often, these dates span different months and even years, affecting the amount you have to pay in taxes to various agencies.  That’s why working with financial professionals is advisable.

Choosing for Your Business

In many cases, the government has chosen which method you must use when it comes to sales tax, payroll taxes, and income tax.  So you may receive adjustments to your books from your accountant for year end.

While many who file on a cash basis run all their reports on a cash basis thinking this is the most accurate, they  miss out on helpful information. To help you run your business in a forward-thinking way, the accrual method is best.  You can record invoices for work you’ve done even though you haven’t received payment yet – many of you probably do that already.  You can enter bills you need to pay before you pay them to forecast cash requirements (Check out our article on this) – I find many skip this useful feature.  By using accrual accounting, you can budget for cash flow needs as well as see more accurately what your revenue and income is looking like.   Accrual can make it easier to see trends in your business.

For clients who remain behind in their bookkeeping and just want to catch everything up once a year, the cash basis is adequate.  However they lose out on all the good information they could have had throughout the year to run their business better.

I usually recommend running your reports on an accrual basis during the year in QuickBooks (you can set the default in the QuickBooks Reporting Company Preference) and then letting your accountant handle the adjustments for cash basis, if that’s how your taxes are filed. However, you can easily switch between the two types in your QuickBooks reports at any time by simply clicking on Customize Report, then selecting the report basis you want.  If you’ve never tried, this, you might be interested in seeing the difference.

A Little Help from Popeye the Sailor

What would Popeye say about all this accounting talk?

“That’s all I can stands, cuz I can’t stands n’more!”

Leave a Reply